Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Anthony Pilla
Refer Me
530 Reviews
Anthony has been in the auto industry for 19 years. He's a huge Giant's fan so watch out. Unfortunately he also likes the Mets. Don't judge him! He's been happily married for 9 years. In his spare time he plays golf, loves fishing and is an ordained minister for those of you looking to get married.
Read moreDealership Experience
9 yrs, 3 mos
Industry Experience
27 yrs, 11 mos
530 Reviews
Write a Review
530 Reviews of Anthony Pilla
February 22, 2024
Great dealership, pleasant, no hard sell. I found the exact car I wanted and got a great deal. This was the most stress free car purchase I’ve ever experienced. Rich and Anthony, the sales I found the exact car I wanted and got a great deal. This was the most stress free car purchase I’ve ever experienced. Rich and Anthony, the salesman, were great to work with. More
by clannab
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
Helpful 
February 09, 2024
Anthony and Rich were amazing! From start to finish. Extremely professional and a painless process . From start to finish. Extremely professional and a painless process . More
by GG
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
January 24, 2024
The sales experience ways pleasant, with no sense of pressure. The financing and warrantee options were explained very clearly, and there were many options to fit our budget. pressure. The financing and warrantee options were explained very clearly, and there were many options to fit our budget. More
by Bebhinn and Ross
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
January 24, 2024
Very professional, pleasant and easy going process! ! I couldn’t be happier with every part of purchasing a new Subaru here. ! I couldn’t be happier with every part of purchasing a new Subaru here. More
by craig9636
Other Employees Tagged: Roy Schiller, Rich Johnson, Mitchel Pollak, Kristen Hetzer, Andre Reid
January 03, 2024
Andre and Rich over at Brewster Subaru are a great team. This is our fourth car with them and enjoy the experience each time. I Highly recommend. This is our fourth car with them and enjoy the experience each time. I Highly recommend. More
by geessgot
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson, Andre Reid
December 31, 2023
Both Anthony and Rich were wonderful. Very informative, organized and a pleasure to work with! Very informative, organized and a pleasure to work with! More
by carsall718
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
December 28, 2023
couldn’t be happier with my recent experience on trading in a 2015 Subaru Legacy for a certified preowned 2022 Subaru legacy. I stepped foot in the dealership and probably the busiest week of the year in De in a 2015 Subaru Legacy for a certified preowned 2022 Subaru legacy. I stepped foot in the dealership and probably the busiest week of the year in December which unfortunately was shortstaffed at the time, but was pleased to find a sales associate who took initiative and help me secure some test drives and negotiate and close the deal other sales associates and see if familiar face in the finance office helped round out and make a time sensitive deal one that was pleasurable and professional. It is a sale experience that I will never forget I can see why the dealership is one of the best in New York if not, the country More
by joesal26
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson , Lexi Lynch
December 05, 2023
The three and a half hour trek we took to buy a car at Subaru Brewster was well worth it. Anthony Pilla and Rich Johnson were very professional, accommodating and helpful. Rich had all of the paperwork r Subaru Brewster was well worth it. Anthony Pilla and Rich Johnson were very professional, accommodating and helpful. Rich had all of the paperwork ready and explained everything to us clearly. We are very thankful for the experience we had at Subaru Brewster! More
by Koro & Tiqvah
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson , Rich Johnson
November 22, 2023
Picked up our Subaru Outback Wilderness this week. My sales representative was Anthony Pilla. From the minute my Wife and I sat down with Anthony , we felt immediately at ease . From our initial discu My sales representative was Anthony Pilla. From the minute my Wife and I sat down with Anthony , we felt immediately at ease . From our initial discussions with regard to the vehicle and its features ,to selecting colors and options , working through the pricing and our trade in , all the way through to delivery was a very pleasant experience. Anthony was extremely knowledgeable of the product, able to answer and clarify all of our questions and was able to quickly match the vehicle options specifications to our needs and priorities and ultimately getting us the exact vehicle that we wanted in line with our budget . No pressure , confusion ,etc. Anthony made certain that we understood all of the costs associated with our car/purchase . Complete transparency. Lastly , Anthony is a gentlemen, a knowledgable professional , polite and courteous. He delivered our car in show car detailed condition and provided us with a complete and detailed walk through of the operation of the vehicle . We also had a pleasant experience with Rich in Finance. Rich was clear, conscience and thorough in finalizing the financial/contract paperwork. Rich presented many additional service and maintenance options without any sales pressure . We did purchase one option during our meeting with Rich as it made total sense for us by virtue of the type of car/vehicle owners we are. Again , no pressure , just professional presentation and provided insights enabling us to make a sensible decision. Rich is a true professional and gentleman. More
by TA1
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
November 21, 2023
What an easy process I am Very happy with service and attention received Thank you attention received Thank you More
by csin524
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
