Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Tim Payton
Refer Me
65 Reviews
65 Reviews
Write a Review
65 Reviews of Tim Payton
March 30, 2024
Tim provided excellent and friendly help and worked with us to get a deal within our budget! All the staff were helpful and got us in our new car quickly! us to get a deal within our budget! All the staff were helpful and got us in our new car quickly! More
by E Charumaneeroj
Helpful 
March 26, 2024
Tim Payton & Diego Rivas were very courteous and professional with the process. Addressed all of my concerns. Would highly recommend this dealership. professional with the process. Addressed all of my concerns. Would highly recommend this dealership. More
by fdior
Other Employees Tagged: Diego Rivas
July 17, 2023
Tim did a great job in getting me the car I wanted. Very professional, honest and knowledgeable. He helped me set my cars programs up as well. Very professional, honest and knowledgeable. He helped me set my cars programs up as well. More
by serfup49
Other Employees Tagged: Greg Kaznocha
April 17, 2023
Great Dealership to work with. They were fair on trade-in. Honest. No gimmicks, no hassle. They made buying a car a pleasant experience. Tim Payton was great to work with. Ke They were fair on trade-in. Honest. No gimmicks, no hassle. They made buying a car a pleasant experience. Tim Payton was great to work with. Kept me informed throughout the process of buying a Highlander Hybrid Platinum. Said it would take 4 months to get and he was right. He was honest. It was a fair deal for a 2023 vehicle. Excellent experience. Recommend Tim and the dealership to everyone. More
by lkick55
March 23, 2023
Simply the best! Tim in sales was a pleasure to work with. John in finance made it simple and explained financing options. One of the best car buying experiences we’ Tim in sales was a pleasure to work with. John in finance made it simple and explained financing options. One of the best car buying experiences we’ve had. No gimmicks here! Totally straight shooters with no hidden fees. Highly recommend Smithtown Toyota if you’re in the market for a new vehicle. More
by Chris P
Other Employees Tagged: John Ferranola
March 10, 2023
Just purchased my second toyota from them in three years, Sean Diets and Diego Rivas make purchasing a vehicle enjoyable, right to the point no haggling they gave the best price and financing available. I wi Sean Diets and Diego Rivas make purchasing a vehicle enjoyable, right to the point no haggling they gave the best price and financing available. I will only purchase from them and encourage anyone I meet who are looking for a vehicle to Smithtown Toyota and to ask for them. More
by Rich
Other Employees Tagged: Sean Dietz, Diego Rivas
February 19, 2023
One of the best car purchase experiences I've ever had. Professional, friendly, and honest! Professional, friendly, and honest! More
by kzacharoff
Other Employees Tagged: John Ferranola
November 29, 2022
We have been buying cars from this dealership for over 30 years. They are so pleasant and helpful. Mike Bourne was our salesman and showed patience and consideration when explaining all the wonderful Toyota years. They are so pleasant and helpful. Mike Bourne was our salesman and showed patience and consideration when explaining all the wonderful Toyota features. We left knowing every detail that would make our experience wonderful. Tim Payton was most helpful in leading us to a perfect car. Thank you Smithtown Toyota for your consideration and help. More
by Laxmom20
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Bourne, John Ferranola
July 07, 2022
Just bought a 2022 Toyota forerunner this was our second purchase with Tim Payton and everything went well. We also met with John to handle the purchase paperwork and we were out quickly with no pressure to purchase with Tim Payton and everything went well. We also met with John to handle the purchase paperwork and we were out quickly with no pressure to buy any additional items. More
by Dom
August 27, 2021
Just got a new Toyota Highlander had a good experience with our salesman Tim at Smithtown Toyota. Car came in and was prepped and waiting for us. Tim spent a good amount of time with my wife going over t with our salesman Tim at Smithtown Toyota. Car came in and was prepped and waiting for us. Tim spent a good amount of time with my wife going over the features. We were at the dealer for a relatively short amount of time and an overall good experience More
by Dom
