

Joshua Croft
Product Specialist
Matthews Hyundai of Schenectady
4101 State Street
Schenectady, NY 12304
We have fun.
Read moreDealership Experience
5 yrs
Industry Experience
5 yrs, 8 mos
149 Reviews
Write a Review149 Reviews of Joshua Croft
May 04, 2025
I liked Josh, the sales person I worked with generally. He has been responsive, but the reality is he cannot overcome the other frustrations I have with the dealership overall. First of all, the process He has been responsive, but the reality is he cannot overcome the other frustrations I have with the dealership overall. First of all, the process of leasing our vehicle was insanely protracted (many hours), and included an "oops, my-bad" type of error from the business manager that resulted in the monthly price we discussed and I had agreed to being misquoted too low after hours of working through everything -- and not by a small amount. By that time, I was stuck (e.g., my ride had left and was an hour away) and we wanted the vehicle so we sucked up the not insignificant difference. At the time I thought it could have been an honest mistake, but given subsequent behaviors, I'm pretty sure I was just being naive and they just took advantage of someone who was too far gone into the deal. Given the "mistake," they promised to compensate me with free upgraded floor mats -- which have yet to come -- literally three months later. I ask regularly and they are always just about to be delivered or sent to me. They even had someone drive to my house and hour away to get a new signature because they used the wrong lease form -- and I was told he would have the mats --- but when I asked where they were, the guy had no clue about it. And still they do not come my way. Lots of "wait, you didn't already get them?" and "let me check with my manager" comments. But there's no reason to believe they will ever come it seems. So let this be a cautionary tale to others planning to lease from them -- if they tell you about a late-in-the-deal error -- it's probably a deceptive practice and you should walk away. Don't do like me and let your ride leave you stranded. Maintain your flexibility to bail until everything is done to your satisfaction. Furthermore, the vehicle is supposed to come with certain CCS charging accessories (as displayed on Hyundai's own website) and every time I ask where they are, I get a "we are looking into it with the Hyundai reps" response. They are critical to the ability to flexibly charge the vehicle and I leased the vehicle under the assumption that we would have these available for our use. This is super frustrating and again makes it feel like they were happy to get me out the door the day I got the car and the rest is my problem. And now when I ask about the adapters, I get very snippy "we told you we'll let you know when we have them" responses. Maybe I'd trust that if I hadn't experienced other points of deception with them. So even though I initially liked Josh and he was super knowledgeable about the vehicle we got, I absolutely cannot recommend working with Matthews again -- between the pricing "mistake" and the non-follow through, it's leaving a really bad impression overall. Others should beware. There are a lot of other Hyundai dealers out there. I recommend you find another. More
Other Employees Tagged: Dylan Mascari
May 03, 2025
Poor service on lease vehicle. Wouldn't replace bent wiper arm. Could have been received that way. No communication or solution offered other than $275.00 to replace. They are losi Wouldn't replace bent wiper arm. Could have been received that way. No communication or solution offered other than $275.00 to replace. They are losing a customer over this. Our third Hyundai. We're going to Garvy. More
Other Employees Tagged: Domonique Scott-Henry, Dejon Lewis, Ryan Ambury
April 30, 2025
Very accommodating, friendly and they do business with a smile. Flexible with schedule. They were so fast. smile. Flexible with schedule. They were so fast. More
Other Employees Tagged: Domonique Scott-Henry , Dominique Scott
April 26, 2025
Josh was so helpful and knowledgeable. He was extremely friendly and made me very comfortable with the whole process. GM Mike was also great, he also made the process wonderful. He was extremely friendly and made me very comfortable with the whole process. GM Mike was also great, he also made the process wonderful. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Capadona
April 20, 2025
We had a wonderful experience at Matthews Hyundai. This has been our dealership for our past two vehicles and each time, the team there was amazing. Very responsive and helpful with all our questions This has been our dealership for our past two vehicles and each time, the team there was amazing. Very responsive and helpful with all our questions and concerns. Could not recommend enough! More
April 20, 2025
Working this Matthews is always a great Experience, Josh has been our sales person each time we are ready to look for a new car and he goes above and beyond to make sure we fully understand the process each has been our sales person each time we are ready to look for a new car and he goes above and beyond to make sure we fully understand the process each step of the way. We were very happy with our experience and our new car! Thank you to the amazing team! More
April 15, 2025
Josh was extremely kind and helpful with getting me through my car situation that I was in. He kept checking in so often to let me know different ideas he was going to try to help me. Overall he was a through my car situation that I was in. He kept checking in so often to let me know different ideas he was going to try to help me. Overall he was a very kind, friendly and helpful. More
Other Employees Tagged: Dalton Hunter
March 28, 2025
Easy to work with. Very pleasant, very accommodating. They have been for the many years I have used them to get my vehicles. There is no other place a would go for my Very pleasant, very accommodating. They have been for the many years I have used them to get my vehicles. There is no other place a would go for my vehicles. More
